Notable Cases & Transactions


MR&T Attorney Thomas J. Fucillo (and former DEC Region 7 Regional Attorney) is representing licensed wildlife rehabilitator Cindy McGinley, owner of Rivendell Farm in the Town of Sullivan, in a proceeding to nullify a determination by DEC which denied her a permit to possess two does and which required that one be euthanized and the other released or euthanized.  Deirdre is five years old and came to Cindy when she was found by a neighbor, only hours old.  The second doe, Lily, is permanently blind.  Lily lost her eyesight due to malnourishment in the wild and came under Cindy’s care when she was three months old.  Although it was hoped that the blindness would be temporary, Lily is now a year old and it is now clear that the condition is permanent.  Lily relies heavily on Deirdre (and Cindy).  Cindy rehabilitated both does back to health, but did not release them believing that neither were adequately equipped to live in the wild.  A DEC officer informed her that she could not lawfully possess them without a permit to possess wildlife.  She immediately applied for that permit but it was denied because DEC considered her to be in violation of her rehabilitation license because she did not have a permit! During the argument of the Article 78 proceeding to be heard on Tuesday, September 8 at 10:30 a.m. by Hon. Donald F. Cerio, Jr. in Madison County Supreme Court in Wampsville, Tom Fucillo, will argue that the denial was arbitrary and capricious and had no rational basis in fact. 




Syracuse Office

Suite 200 • 308 Maltbie Street

Syracuse, New York 13204-1439

Phone: (315) 474-7541

Fax: (315) 474-4040




Watertown Office

Suite 500 • 120 Washington Street

Watertown, New York 13601-3330

Phone: (315) 786-7950

Fax: (315) 786-7852


Smarter Approach. Faster Response. All Business.


Menter, Rudin & Trivelpiece, P.C. is a nationally-recognized, business law firm. For more than 65 years, we have provided our clients with superior legal representation in a wide area of disciplines.


The firm is proud that U.S. News & World Report has rated it a Tier 1 law firm - the highest ranking - in three practice areas: Banking and Finance Law; Bankruptcy and Creditor-Debtor Rights/Insolvency and Reorganization Law; and Commercial Litigation.


Our practice groups include Alternative Dispute Resolution, Banking Law, Business Restructuring & Bankruptcy, Commercial Transactions, Construction Law, Continuing Care Service, Creditors' Rights, Environmental Law, Estate & Elder Law Planning, Labor Relations & Employment Law, Litigation, Municipal Law, Personal Injury and Real Estate.


We strive to understand our clients' concerns and goals, and focus on project management, risk evaluation and avoidance, and on-going communications to meet those goals. Menter, Rudin & Trivelpiece, P.C. employs an interdisciplinary approach by drawing on the skills offered by the appropriate practice groups and industry-specific professionals to handle each case. Our attorneys take pride in their ability to provide efficient solutions to the challenges that our clients encounter in the face of aggressive opponents and rapidly changing technology.


With fully staffed offices in both Syracuse and Watertown, we practice throughout New York State and extend our resources across the country, as necessary. We take a no-nonsense approach with our clients and dedicate only the most appropriate resources.



2013 Top Ranked Law Firm by LexisNexis


Martindale Hubbell®